Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Northern Ireland Courts And Tribunals Service would like to place cookies on your computer to help make this website better. To find out more about the cookies, see our Privacy Policy.

Other

This Table contains all published decisions of the Tribunal from 1990 (and selected earlier ones) which are categorised in the other section.

The Business Tenancies, Rating and Pre-1990 Domestic Rating are available by clicking on the links available on the left hand side of this page

A Key to Legislation is included at the end.

Caution: This table provides no more than aid to research and should be not be treated as a substitute for legal advice or detailed case preparation.

Use "Edit" and "Find" to search for cases relevant to particular issues. Click on the Short Title to see a case summary (not complete). (Lands Tribunal Case Summaries prepared by Dr William McCluskey, University of Ulster.) Click on the Lands Tribunal Reference to see the Decision in full. This will open a new page where the document can be viewed in a variety of formats.

With users' co-operation the Table will be improved. Please contact the Registrar, Kevin McQuillan at lands.tribunal@dfpni.gov.uk with corrections and suggestions for improvements (including suggestions for other earlier Decisions to be added).

Short Title Principal Act or LOrder BNIL Citation or Year Lands Tribunal Reference Property Location Main Issue Other or Subsidiary Issue Significant Other Issues or Legislation Attachments
​NIHE v Clipper Holding ​LGA72  ​[2017] ​R/11/2017 ​Stratheden St, Belfast ​Compensation ​Monies payable to mortgagee ​Land Clauses Act ​1. R/11/2017.pdf​

2. R/11/2017.doc​
​Wylie v Gibson ​PO78 ​[2017] ​R/6/2016 ​Grey Point, Helen’s Bay ​Restrictive covenant ​Permission

​1. R/6/2016.pdf

2. R/6/2016.doc

​G McGreevy Construction v Hollywood ​PO78 ​[2017] ​R/27/2016 ​Crieve Rd, Newry ​Restrictive covenant ​Change in locality

​1. R/27/2016.pdf

2. R/27/2016.doc

​Rockville v Lyttle & Others ​PO78 ​[2017] ​R/33/2009 ​Station Rd, Craigavad ​Restrictive covenant ​No build impediment

​1. R/33/2009.pdf

2. R/33/2009.doc

​H Gillespi v White (2) ​PO78 ​[2017] ​R/9/2015 ​Church Rd, Dundonald ​Costs ​Costs on costs

​​1. R/9/2015.pdf

2. R/9/2015.doc

​NIHE v Mulgrew (2) ​HO81 ​[2017] ​R/16 & 17/2016 ​Duncairn Gdns, Belfast ​Costs ​Allowable

​​1. R/16&17/2016.pdf

​2. R/16&17/2016.doc

​H Gillespi v White (1) ​PO78 ​[2017] ​R/9/2015 ​Church Rd, Dundonald ​Costs ​Withdrawal ​Amount of Costs

​1. R/9/2015.pdf

2. R/9/2015.doc

​NIHE v Mulgrew (1) ​HO81 ​[2017] ​R/16 & 17/2016 ​Duncairn Gdns, Belfast ​Compensation ​Redevelopment scheme

​1. R/16&17/2016.pdf

2. R/16&17/2016.doc

​Bradley v Dittmar ​PO78 ​[2017] ​R/4/2016 ​High St, Portadown ​Right of way ​Modification

​1. R/4/2016.pdf

2. R/4/2016.doc

​Deuxberry & Ors v Dept of Infrastructure (2) ​LTCA64 ​[2016] ​R/22/2013 ​Victoria Rd, Burndennett, Strabane ​Costs on costs ​Allocation

​1. R/22/2016.pdf

2. R/22/2016.doc

​NIHE v UCB Home Loans & Ano ​LGA72 ​[2016] ​R/18/2016 ​Monarch St, Belfast ​Compensation ​Paid to mortgagee 

​1. R/18/2016.pdf

2. R/18/2016.doc

​Menary v Bolton & Ors PO78​​ ​[2016] ​R/21/2016 ​Old Coach Lane, Moneymore Rd, Cookstown ​Restrictive covenant ​Right of way

​1. R/21/2016.pdf

2. R/21/2016.doc

​Overdale Mushrooms (2) ​PO78 ​[2016] ​ ​​R/2/2016 ​Old Grand Jury Rd, Saintfield ​Property Order ​Restrictive covenant ​Declaration that none existed ​1. R/2/2016.pdf
2. R/2/2016.doc​
​​Wallace v DRD (2) ​LTCA64​​ ​[2016]  ​R/1/2016  ​Frosses Rd, Cloughmills ​Compensation  ​Accommodation works ​Jurisdiction of the Tribunal​ ​1. ​R/1/2016.pdf
2. R/1/2016.doc​
​Deuxberry & Ors v Dept for Infrastructure ​LGA72 ​[2016] ​R/22/2016 ​Victoria Rd, Burndennett, Strabane ​Costs ​Amount of costs ​Reasonable costs

​1. R/22/2016.pdf

2. R/22/2016.word

​Overdale Mushrooms ​PO78​ ​[2016] R/2/2016​​ ​Old Grand Jury Rd, Saintfield​ ​Property Order​ ​Restrictive covenant​ ​Declaration that none existed

​1. R/2/2016.pdf

2. R/2/2016.doc

​Wallace v DRD LTCA64​ [2016]​ ​R/1/2016 ​Frosses Rd, Cloughmills Compensation​ Accomodation works​ Jurisdiction of the Tribunal​

​1. R/1/2016.pdf

2. R/1/2016.doc

​McCormack v NIE ​LTR76 ​[2015] ​R/22/2014 ​Tulnacross Rd, Cookstown ​NIE Compensation ​Failure to comply with directions ​''Unless order''

​1. R/22/2014.pdf

2. R/22/2014.doc

NIHE v Foster & Ors​ LGA 72​ [2015] R/6/2015 Soudan St, Belfast Land Compensation Amount​ Paid to mortgagee​

1. R/6/2015.pdf

2. R/6/2015.doc

Mayers V COV ​ RO77​ [2015] VR/3/2014​ Corporation St, Enniskillen​ Rates Exemption​ Rateable occupier​ Exclusive Occupation​

1. VR/3/2014.pdf

2. VR/3/2014.doc​

NIHE v Patterson & Ors​ LGA72​ [2015]​ R/14-15 & 18/2014​ Broadway Parade/Ebor St/Kitchener St, Belfast ​ LCC Act 1845​ Compensation awarded to mortgagor​

1. R/14-15&18/2014.pdf

2. R/14-15&18/2014.doc

Hunt & Anr v Belvoir Golf Club (3)​ P078​ [2014]​ R/86/2007​ Church Rd, Newtownbreda​ Costs​ Costs on costs​

    1. R/86/2007.pdf

    2. R/86/2007.doc

NIHE v Magee Ors LGA72 [2015] R/16 & 17/2014 Soudan St/ Ebor St, Belfast Compensation Award to mortgagee

 1. R/16&17/2014.pdf

 2. R/16&17/2014.doc

Chivers v NI Water WS73 [2015] R/43/2011 Drumsurn Rd, Limavady Preliminary point Execution of works Physical Damage

     1. R/43/2011.pdf

     2. R/43/2011.doc

Hunt & Anr v Belvoir Golf Club (2)​ PO78​ [2014] R/86/2007 Church Rd, Newtownbreda Costs Amount for expert witness

     1. R/86/2007.pdf

     2. R/86/2007.doc

Brickklin Waste v NIE (3)​ EO92​ [2015]​ R/41/2009​ Electra Rd, Maydown​ Costs​ Award less than amount of claim​

1. R/41/2009.pdf

2. R/41/2009.doc

Cassidy v NIE (2)​ EO92​ [2015]​ R/49/2011​ Finsbury Cres, Belfast​ Costs​ No Compensation​

1. R/49/2011.pdf

2. R/49/2011.doc

McKibben v NIE (2)​ EO92​ [2015]​ R/52/2011​ Glenholm Pk, Belfast​ Costs​ Award less than amount of claim​

1. R/52/2011.pdf

2. R/52/2011.doc

Cuthbert v NIE (2)​ EO92​ [2015]​ R/26/2011​ Maydown Rd, Londonderry​ Costs​ No Compensation​

1. R/26/2011.pdf

2. R/26/2011.doc

Dobbin​ PO78​ [2014]​ R/2/2013​ Coast Rd, Drains Bay, Larne ​ Restrictive covenant​ Modification​
  1. R/2/2013​.pdf
  2. R/2/2013.doc​
Brickklin Waste v NIE (2)​ EO92​ [2014]​ R/41/2009​ Electra Rd, Maydown ​
 
Compensation NIE Equipment
 
Waste disposal premises​
  1. R/41/2009.pdf
  2. R/41/2009.doc
Cassidy v NIE ​ EO92​ [2014]​ R/49/2011​ Finsbury Cres, Belfast ​
 
Compensation NIE Equipment
 
Oversailing power lines, residential premises​
  1. R/49/2011.pdf
  2. R/49/2011.doc​
Cuthbert v NIE ​ EO92​ [2014]​ R/26/2011​ Maydown Rd, Londonderry ​
 
Compensation NIE Equipment
 
Land zoned for industrial use​
  1. R/26/2011.pdf
  2. R/26/2011.doc​
McKibben v NIE ​E092 ​[2014] ​R/52/2011 ​Glenholm Pk, Belfast
Compensation NIE Equipment
 
​NIE Equipment
  1. R/52/2011.pdf
  2. R/52/2011.doc

Orchard Caravans v DOE (1)

LDV65

[1983] LDV/1/1981 Ballymagarry & Tanderagee, Co Antrim Compensation
  1. LDV-1-1981_1.pdf
  2. LDV-1-1981_1.doc
Orchard Caravans v DOE (2) LDV65 [1983] LDV/1/1981 Ballymagarry & Tanderagee, Co Antrim Interest
  1. LDV-1-1981_2.doc
  2. LDV-1-1981_2.pdf
Pantridge v DOE PLCA71 [1977] R/1/1977 Collin House, Dunmurry Blight Material detriment
  1. R-1-1977.doc
  2. R-1-1977.pdf
Allister & Anr v Kerr PO78 [1982] 3/61 R/1/1981 Bachelor's Walk, Lisburn Compensation Modification Practical benefit; Valuation date; Downlift for historic values.
  1. R-1-1981.pdf
  2. R-1-1981.doc
S D Bell v DOE RD48 [1988] R/1/1987 Upper Newtownards Rd, Belfast Tenancy Compensatable interest Limitation
  1. R-1-1987.doc
  2. R-1-1987.pdf
Farquharson & Ors PO78 [1995] 2/43 R/1/1994 Station Rd, Craigavad Modification Unreasonable No compensation
  1. R-1-1994.doc
  2. R-1-1994.pdf
Napier v Nurse PO78 [1996] 2/59 R/1/1996 Earlswood Rd, Belfast Costs Withdrawal Academic
  1. R-1-1996.pdf
  2. R-1-1996.doc
Curley & Ors v NIHE (1) LC82 [2003] 5/62 R/1/2003 & R/5/2003 Cawnpore St & Clonard Gdns, Belfast Disturbance Legal costs New house; delay
  1. R-1___5-2003.doc
  2. R/1/2003
Maguire v DOE LC82 [1992] R/10/1992 Rossole Rd, Enniskillen Market value Disturbance Garden
  1. R-10-1992.doc
  2. R-10-1992.pdf
Bell v SEBHSS Trust (1) LAC73 [2004] 9/60 R/10/2002 Lisburn Rd, Belfast Jurisdiction Disturbance
  1. R-10-2002__1_.doc
  2. R-10-2002.pdf
Bell v SEBHSS Trust (2) LAC73 [2005] R/10/2002 Lisburn Rd, Belfast Costs Compulsory Acquisition
  1. R-10-2002__2_.doc
  2. R-10-2002.pdf
Benner v NIHE PLCA71 [1977] R/11/1974 Donegall Pass, Belfast Blight Occupation
  1. R-11-1974.doc
  2. R-11-1974.pdf
Bell & Ors v Nixon & Ors PO78 [1995] 2/42 R/11/1994 Hamilton Rd, Bangor Unreasonable Practical benefit Nominal compensation
  1. R-11-1994.pdf
  2. R-11-1994.doc
Davies & Anr v Greene PO78 [2009] 6/70 R/11/2008 Jordanstown Rd, Newtownabbey Costs Withdrawal
  1. R-13-1996.doc
  2. R-11-2008.pdf
Hill v DOE PLCA71 [1975] R/12/1975 Glencraig Pk, Craigavad Blight Material detriment
  1. R-12-1975.doc
  2. R-12-1975.pdf
Donnelly v NIHE LC82 [1996] 3/56 R/12/1995 Benares St, Belfast Market value Expert evidence Sales and settlements
  1. R-12-1995.pdf
  2. R-12-1995.doc
Curley & Ors v NIHE (2) LC82 [2004] 8/53 R/1-2/2003 & R/5/2003 Cawnpore St & Clonard Gdns, Belfast Disturbance Causal connection Solicitors costs
  1. R-1-2___5-2003.pdf
  2. R-1-2___5-2003.doc
Smyth v Clark & Rankin PO78 [1991] 5/72 R/13/1991 William St, Bellaghy Easement Nature & extent Jurisdiction; extinguishment
  1. R-13-1991.pdf
  2. R-13-1991.doc
McKee & Ors v O'Callaghan PO78 [1995] 3/81 R/13/1993 Ogle St, Armagh Modification Unreasonable Liquor licence
  1. R-13-1993.doc
  2. R-13-1993.pdf
Armagh Diocesan Board of Education PO78 [1995] 4/73 R/13/1994 Carrickmore, Co Tyrone Modification Obsolete Former school & house; church hall; compensation
  1. R-13-1994.pdf
  2. R-13-1994.doc
Neilson v NIHE LC82 [1996] 4/61 R/13/1995 Dunmore St, Belfast Disturbance Mortgage indemnity premium Decoration
  1. R-13-1995.pdf
  2. R-13-1995.doc
Wilson v DRD PBO81 [2008] 4/73 R/13/1996 Ballynure Rd, Newtownabbey Costs Blight Notice
  1. R-13-1996.pdf
  2. R-13-1996.doc
Carney v DOE WS73 [1994] 4/62 R/14/1992 Devon Ct, Rathenraw Jurisdiction Execution of works MD69; LG72
  1. R-14-1992.pdf
  2. R-14-1992.doc
McIlroy & Ors PO78 [1996] 4/63 R/15/1996 Raloo Extinguishment Unreasonable Trust
  1. R-15-1996.doc
  2. R-15-1996.pdf
Treacy v Down DC LAC73 [2009] 10/82 R/15/2005 Killough Port, Killough Limitation Waiver? Limitation (NI) Order 1989
  1. R-15-2005.doc
  2. R-15-2005.pdf
Browne Ltd v DOE RD80 [1990] 9/55 R/16/1987 Dublin Rd Valuation method Residual Comparable; RT81
  1. R-16-1987.doc
  2. R-16-1987.pdf
Todd v Unwin & Ors LE71 [1993] 2/90 R/16/1992 Avondale Dr, Ballyclare Assignment Intention Scope; sub-lease upheld on Appeal - see [1994] 7/71
  1. R-16-1992.doc
  2. R-16-1992.pdf
Bell v Ker LE71 [1995] 8/41 R/16/1994 Main St, Ballynahinch By reason of Strict interpretation Expropriator; right attached to land; technicalities
  1. R-16-1994.pdf
  2. R-16-1994.doc
Multiple Sclerosis Society PO78 [1997] 8/40 R/16/1997 Annadale Av, Belfast Benefit Modification Compensation
  1. R-16-1997.pdf
  2. R-16-1997.doc
Ward & Anr v NIHE (1) PO78 [2004] 2/65 R/16/2002 Old Dundonald Rd, Dundonald Compensation Holding Comparables; unrestricted value; marriage
  1. R-16-2002__1_.doc
  2. R-16-2002__1_.pdf
Ward & Anr v NIHE (2) PO78 [2004] 10/80 R/16/2002 Old Dundonald Rd, Dundonald Costs
  1. R-16-2002__2_.pdf
  2. R-16-2002__2_.doc
McLean v NIHE PLCA71 [1976] R/17/1974 Ormeau Rd, Belfast Blight Licence
  1. R-17-1974.pdf
  2. R-17-1974.doc
Loughran LE71 [1991] 2/66 R/17/1990 Main St, Keady Purchase Price Registrar
  1. R-17-1990.pdf
  2. R-17-1990.doc
Andrews v Davis PO78 [1995] 3/81 R/17/1993 The Dub Stores, Belfast Benefit Unreasonable Public interest; practical benefit; profit motive; liquor licence; compensation
  1. R-17-1993.pdf
  2. R-17-1993.doc
Hewitt & Ors v O'Neill & Ors PO78 [2008] R/17/2006 Cleaver Av, Cleaver Gdns & Cleaver Pk, Belfast Benefit Building Scheme Ground Rents Act (NI) 2001
  1. R-17-2006.pdf
  2. R-17-2006.doc
McGonigal v DOE PLCA71 [1975] R/18/1975 Hawthornden Rd, Belfast Blight Valuation date Interest
  1. R-18-1975.doc
  2. R-18-1975.pdf
Mitchell v DOE PLCA71 [1978] R/18/1977 Charles St, Lurgan Blight No proposal
  1. R-18-1977.doc
  2. R-18-1977.pdf
McCarney v Martin PO78 [1989] 1/106 R/18/1988 Gilnahirk Rd, Belfast Compensation Modification Compensation for bargaining power; Uplift for current values
  1. R-18-1988.doc
  2. R-18-1988.pdf
Gillespie v Trustees Portadown Masonic Hall PO78 [1991] 1/66 R/18/1991 Carleton St, Portadown Leave Recent
  1. R-18-1991.doc
  2. R-18-1991.pdf
Haslett v DOE LAC73 [1995] 5/62 R/18/1993 Upper Knockbreda Rd, Belfast Depreciation Physical factors Burden; expert evidence
  1. R-18-1993.pdf
  2. R-18-1993.doc
McIntyre v DOE PO91 [1996] 9/67 R/19/1992 & R/4/1994 Arcadia Portrush Compensation Market value LG72; LC82; expert's role; costs; purchase notice
  1. R-19-1992___R-4-1994.pdf
  2. R-19-1992___R-4-1994.doc
Lunney v NIHE LC82 [1996] 4/60 R/19/1995 Cupar St, Belfast Prospect of possession Duty to rehouse Galbraith v DOE [1991] 8/59 not followed; AL19; LAC73
  1. R-19-1995.doc
  2. R-19-1995.pdf
Greer v NIHE LAC73 [1997] 10/56 R/19/1996 Rosewood St, Belfast Disturbance Expert evidence Duty; transparency; intuitive approach
  1. R-19-1996.doc
  2. R-19-1996.pdf
Hawe v NIHE LC82 [1998] 6/64 R/19/1997 Albertville Dr, Belfast Market value Expert evidence Transparency; sales and settlements
  1. R-19-1997.pdf
  2. R-19-1997.doc
O'Neill & Ors v NIHE LC82 [2005] R/2, 3 & 4/2004 Havana Gdns, Belfast Disturbance Fees LAC73
  1. R-2__3___4-2004.pdf
  2. R-2__3___4-2004.doc
Barbour & Payne v DANI DO73 [1990] 7/85 R/2/1988 Bridge St, Comber Flooding Damage Set off
  1. R-2-1988.doc
  2. R-2-1988.pdf
Mullan & Ors PO78 [1993] 1/77 R/20/1992 Antrim Rd, Newtownabbey Modification Unreasonable Trust
  1. R-20-1992.doc
  2. R-20-1992.pdf
Galbraith v DOE LC82 [1991] 8/59 R/21/1989 Irwin Av, Belfast Compensation Possession See [1996] 4/60 - R/19/1995
  1. R-21-1989.pdf
  2. R-21-1989.doc
Queen's University PO78 [1990] 10/44 R/21/1990 Derryvolgie House, Malone, Belfast Extinguishment Unreasonable Unit
  1. R-21-1990.pdf
  2. R-21-1990.doc
Lindberg v NIHE LC82 [1997] 8/39 R/21/1995 Trallee St, Belfast Disturbance Mortgage interest Set off; LG72
  1. R-21-1995.doc
  2. R-21-1995.pdf
Watt v NIHE (1) LC82 [2004] R/21/2002 Euston Parade, Belfast Tenancy Protected tenancy Rent (NI) Order 1978; Housing (NI) Order 1983
  1. R-21-2002.pdf
  2. R-21-2002.doc
Watt v NIHE (2) LC82 [2006] 7/70 R/21/2002 Euston Parade, Belfast Costs Amount
  1. R-21-2002__2_.doc
  2. R-21-2002__2_.pdf
Houston v DOE AER71 [1990] 10/5 R/22/1990 Eglinton Trees Directions
  1. R-22-1990.pdf
  2. R-22-1990.doc
Rev Cromie & Ors PO78 [1992] 7/59 R/23/1991 Fort Lands, Hilden Extinguishment Unreasonable Objectors
  1. R-23-1991.pdf
  2. R-23-1991.doc
Gallagher v DOE RD80 [1991] 2/62 R/25/1989 Ballymagroary, Londonderry Compensation Betterment Existing use
  1. R-25-1989.doc
  2. R-25-1989.pdf
Milligan v DOE PO72 [2002] 4/54 R/25/1997 Edenaclough Wood, Fermanagh Admissibility of expert evidence Prospect of planning permission PO91
  1. R-25-1997.doc
  2. R-25-1997.pdf
McCreesh v NIHE LAC73 [2005] 3/73 R/26/2003 Stewartstown Rd, Belfast Jurisdiction Disturbance
  1. R-26-2003.pdf
  2. R-26-2003.doc
Fortwilliam Golf Club v DRD WS73 [2010] R/27/2005 Fortwilliam, Belfast Costs Expert Witness Changed valuers
  1. R-27-2005.pdf
  2. R-27-2005.doc
Brooks v NIHE LAC73 [2009] R/27/2007 Alexandra Pk Av, Belfast Costs Premature Ryde's Scale
  1. R-27-2007.pdf
  2. R-27-2007.doc
Neill v Reps Gray LE71 [1991] 7/129 R/29/1990 Kells Conveyance Execution Registrar
  1. R-29-1990.pdf
  2. R-29-1990.doc
Clarke v Black LE71 [1993] 8/48 R/29/1992 Portaferry Rd, Newtownards Valuation
  1. R-29-1992.pdf
  2. R-29-1992.doc
Eastwood v DOE PLCA71 [1983] R/30/1982 Fountain Rd, Cookstown Blight Second notice
  1. R-30-1982.doc
  2. R-30-1982.pdf
MacRae v DOE PLCA71 [1985] R/30/1983 Donegall Rd, Belfast Blight Disturbance
  1. R-30-1983.pdf
  2. R-30-1983.doc
Butler v NIHE LC82 [1990] 8/37 R/30/1988 Eia St, Belfast Possession Mortgagee
  1. R-30-1988.pdf
  2. R-30-1988.doc
Castlereagh BC v NIHE PO78 [2003] R/30/2002 & R/32/2002 Ballyhanwood, Belfast Compensation Indexation RPI

 

  1. R-30___32-2002.doc
Scalene v DSD LC82 [2008] R/30/2005 Ann St & Upper Church Lane, Belfast Market value Rent Scheme
  1. R-30-2005.doc
  2. R-30-2005.pdf
Swann v DOE RD80 [1991] 9/75 R/31/1989 Dunsilly Rd, Antrim Jurisdiction Transfer of land RD48
  1. R-31-1989.doc
  2. R-31-1989.pdf
Cotter & Anr v DRD PBO81 [2009] R/33/2008 Shore Rd, Greenisland Costs Withdrawal
  1. R-33-2008.pdf
  2. R-33-2008.doc
Clancy Ltd & Ors v Presbyterian Widow's PO78 [1996] 3/57 R/34/1995 Ravenscroft Av, Belfast Modification Practical benefit
  1. R-34-1995.doc
  2. R-34-1995.pdf
Drayne v St Patrick's Trust PO78 [2009] R/34/2006 Jockey Lane, Moy Modification Neighbour
  1. R-34-2006.pdf
  2. R-34-2006.doc
Limbo v DRD LC82 [2011] R/34/2009 Greenland St, Belfast Costs Assessment
  1. R-34-2009.pdf
  2. R-34-2009.DOC
Ross v Johnston (1) PO78 [2000] 2/57 R/35/1998 Upper Rd, Greenisland Leave Original coventaor Effect; fee farm grant
  1. R-35-1998__1_.pdf
  2. R-35-1998__1_.doc
Ross v Johnston (2) PO78 [2002] 2/57 R/35/1998 Upper Rd, Greenisland Costs Proportion Conduct
  1. R-35-1998__2_.doc
  2. R-35-1998__2_.pdf
McDonald v Geddis & Hobson PO78 [2000] R/35/1999 Warren Rd, Donaghadee Costs Late withdrawal
  1. R-35-1999.pdf
  2. R-35-1999.doc
Ashfield v Lowe PO78 [2005] 1/66 R/35/2000 Tyrone Costs Assessment
  1. R-35-2000.doc
  2. R-35-2000.pdf
McKillen & Ors v Ferguson & Anr (1) PO78 [2003] R/35/2002 Ashley Pk, Dunmurry Modification Premature Road widening; density
  1. R-35-2002__1_.doc
  2. R-35-2002__1_.pdf
McKillen & Ors v Ferguson & Anr (2) PO78 [2005] 7/91 R/35/2002 Ashley Pk, Dunmurry Costs Application Time
  1. R-35-2002__2_.pdf
  2. R-35-2002__2_.doc
Nicholas PO78 [1990] 7/88 R/36/1989 Derryvolgie Av, Belfast Extinguishment Unreasonable Repairing
  1. R-36-1989.doc
  2. R-36-1989.pdf
Hay & Ors PO78 [1996] 4/63 R/36/1995 Victoria Hall, Londonderry Extinguishment Benefits & burdens Unreasonable
  1. R-36-1995.doc
  2. R-36-1995.pdf
McKeag v NIHE LC82 [1999] R/36/1998 Rosewood St, Belfast Compensation Market value Comparables; settlements; market transactions
  1. R-36-1998.pdf
  2. R-36-1998.doc
Laing & Hurley PO78 [1990] 7/87 R/37/1989 Kinnegar Rd, Holywood Modification Unreasonable
  1. R-37-1989.doc
  2. R-37-1989.pdf
Eccles & Ors v NIHE (1) LC82 [1990] 9/54 R/38/1988 Park St, Coleraine Basis of compensation Unfit house LAC73; HO81; prospects of possession; licencees
  1. R-38-1988__1_.doc
  2. R-38-1988__1_.pdf
Eccles & Ors v NIHE (2) LC82 [1991] 2/63 R/38/1988 (2) Park St, Coleraine No scheme world Planning assumptions
  1. R-38-1988__1_.doc
  2. R-38-1988__1_.pdf
Howard King & Partners v DSD LGA72 [2009] R/39/2008 Montgomery St, Belfast Withdrawal Costs
  1. R-39-2008.pdf
  2. R-39-2008.doc
Salvation Army v DOE PLCA71 [1987] R/4/1987 Oldpark Rd, Belfast Blight Time limit see R/5/1988
  1. R-4-1987.pdf
  2. R-4-1987.doc
Walkington v Orr (1) PO78 [2001] 6/90 R/4/2000 Portavogie Costs Withdrawal Right of way
  1. R-4-2000.pdf
  2. R-4-2000.doc
Stewart v Gorman & Cotton, Turnbull & Watt LE71 [1992] 7/56 R/40/1991 Mill Pk, Ballymena Notice Service Residential qualification
  1. R-40-1991.pdf
  2. R-40-1991.doc
McMahon & Anr v Kingsmoat (1) PO78 [2003] 7/66 R/40/2002 & R/41/2002 Kings Rd, Belfast Whether impediment Business profitability Self certification
  1. R-40___41-2002__1_.pdf
  2. R-40___41-2002__1_.doc
McMahon & Anr v Kingsmoat (2) PO78 [2003] R/40/2002 & R/41/2002 Kings Rd, Belfast Costs Proportionate award Subsidiary questions
  1. R-40___41-2002__2_.pdf
  2. R-40___41-2002__2_.doc
Connon v DOE RD93 [2001] 5/97 R/41/1998 Queen St, Ballymena Development site Liquor licence Valuation method LO90
  1. R-41-1998.pdf
  2. R-41-1998.doc
Brady v NIHE LC82 [2001] 5/94 R/41/1999 Spamount St, Belfast Disturbance Causal connection New house; legal costs; intention
  1. R-41-1999.doc
  2. R-41-1999.pdf
McGrath & Anr v O'Neill & Ors (1) PO78 [2005] 4/88 R/41/2004 Coleraine Rd, Portstewart Compensation Breach Conduct
  1. R-41-2004__1_.pdf
  2. R-41-2004__1_.doc
McGrath & Anr v O'Neill & Ors (2) PO78 [2005] 10/78 R/41/2004 Coleraine Rd, Portstewart Costs Offers Conduct
  1. R-41-2004__2_.doc
  2. R-41-2004__2_.pdf
Eastonville v Gillespie & Ors (1) PO78 [2007] R/41/2006 Holborn Av, Bangor Whether impediment Interpretation of agreement
  1. R-41-2006_2.doc
  2. R-41-2006_2.pdf
Eastonville v Gillespie & Ors (2) PO78 [2010] R/41/2006 Holborn Av, Bangor Court Order Practical Benefit
  1. R-41-2006.doc
  2. R-41-2006.pdf
Hamill LE71 [1990] 7/86 R/43/1989 Hazelbank Rd, Ballymena Conveyance Registrar
  1. R-43-1989.doc
  2. R-43-1989.pdf
Clarke PO78 [1993] 1/77 R/44/1991 Deerpark Rd, Belfast Modification Unreasonable
  1. R-44-1991.doc
  2. R-44-1991.pdf
Joel Ltd & McKinstry v Jamison PO78 [1991] 1/74 R/45/1988 Downview Pk, Greenisland Benefit Modification Unreasonable; Specific
  1. R-45-1988.pdf
  2. R-45-1988.doc
Danesfort v Morrow & Palmer (1) PO78 [2001] 6/89 R/45/1999 Stranmillis Rd, Belfast Benefit Adjoining land
  1. R-45-1999__1_.doc
  2. R-45-1999__1_.pdf
Danesfort v Morrow & Palmer (2) PO78 [2002] 4/55 R/45/1999 Stranmillis Rd, Belfast Modification Practical benefit Amenity & character; privacy & seclusion; planning permission
  1. R-45-1999__2_.doc
  2. R-45-1999__2_.pdf
O'Brien v DANI DO73 [1991] 9/76 R/46/1990 Caledon River Erosion Compensation
  1. R-46-1990.doc
  2. R-46-1990.pdf
Corry v Hall/ Kennedy Estate PO78 [1996] 3/58 R/46/1995 Cultra Benefit Practical benefit
  1. R-46-1995.pdf
  2. R-46-1995.doc
Mulholland & Anr v Invest NI LC82 [2006] 6/76 R/46/2005 Blackpark Rd, Toomebridge Compensation Planning Roads
  1. R-46-2005.pdf
  2. R-46-2005.doc
Graham v NIHE HO81 [1991] 6/66 R/48/1990 Colchester St, Belfast Occupier Family Site value
  1. R-48-1990.doc
  2. R-48-1990.pdf
Mulholland v NIHE (1) LC82 [2005] 9/75 R/48/2004 Gainsborough Dr, Belfast Compensation
  1. R-48-2004__1_.doc
  2. R-48-2004__1_.pdf
Mulholland v NIHE (2) LC82 [2007] 9/78 R/48/2004 Gainsborough Dr, Belfast Costs
  1. R-48-2004__2_.pdf
  2. R-48-2004__2_.doc
McNicholl v Mullan & Anr PO78 [2001] R/49/1999 Chapel Hill, Cookstown Jurisdiction Blank cheque Nature & extent; trade or business; restraint of trade; admissibility
  1. R-49-1999.doc
  2. R-49-1999.pdf
O'Neill v NIHE (1) LC82 [2010] R/49/2009 Glenwood St & Battenburg St, Belfast Compensation Negative equity
  1. R-49-2009.pdf
  2. R-49-2009.doc
O'Neill v NIHE (2) LC82 [2011] R/49/2009 Glenwood St & Battenburg St, Belfast Costs Compulsory Purchase
  1. R-49-2009 (2).pdf
  2. R-49-2009 (2).doc
Glenwherry v NIHE PLCA71 [1974] R/5/1974 Shaftesbury Sq, Belfast Blight Qualifiying interest
  1. R-5-1974.doc
  2. R-5-1974.pdf
Salvation Army v DOE PLCA71 [1988] R/5/1988 Oldpark Rd, Belfast Blight Time limit see R/4/1987
  1. R-5-1988.pdf
  2. R-5-1988.doc
Crossan v DOE RT81 [1993] 6/64 R/5/1992 Mill St, Comber Damage Road closure WS73; private right
  1. R-5-1992.pdf
  2. R-5-1992.doc
Tesco PO78 [2001] 1/42 R/50/1999 Orritor Rd, Cookstown Modification Trustees Sunday trading, liquor licence
  1. R-50-1999.pdf
  2. R-50-1999.doc
Kamack v Stinson & Anr PO78 [2009] R/52/2007 Prospect Rd, Portstewart Modification Neighbour
  1. R-52-2007.pdf
  2. R-52-2007.doc
Bunting v NIHE LC82 [2003] 10/91 R/53/2002 Rathlin St, Belfast Disturbance Fees LAC73
  1. R-53-2002.doc
  2. R-53-2002.pdf
Spanboard v The Crown PO78 [2007] 9/78 R/56/2004 Costs
  1. R-56-2004.pdf
  2. R-56-2004.doc
Hyde Ltd v DOE PLCA71 [1974] R/6/1974 Armagh Rd, Portadown Blight Appropriate authority
  1. R-6-1974.doc
  2. /R-6-1974.pdf
Ulster Friends Trustees Ltd PO78 [1992] 7/59 R/6/1992 Richhill Extinguishment Unreasonable
  1. R-6-1992.doc
  2. R-6-1992.pdf
Erwin & Anr LE71 [1995] 1/42 R/6/1993 Kinhilt St, Ballymena Residential qualification Purchase price Paid into Court; Registrar
  1. R-6-1993.pdf
  2. R-6-1993.doc
Maxol v DOE LG72 [2004] R/60/1999 The Harbour, Carrickfergus Non-occupation Equivalence Solus agreement PO 91
  1. R-60-1999.pdf
  2. R-60-1999.doc
Oaklee v Lynas PO78 [2006] R/62/2004 Rosetta Av, Belfast Breach Modification Lessor's discretion
  1. R-62-2004.pdf
  2. R-62-2004.doc
Spruce v Palmer PO78 [2004] R/63/2003 Danesfort, Stranmillis Rd, Belfast PLV Implied agreement See also R/45/1999 Parts 1 & 2
  1. R-63-2003.doc
  2. R-63-2003.pdf
Conville & Anr (1) PO78 [2002] 2/70 R/64/2000 Carney Hill, Craigavad Benefit Restrictive Scheme; positive
  1. R-64-2000__1_.pdf
  2. R-64-2000__1_.doc
Conville & Anr (2) PO78 [2002] 2/70 R/64/2000 Carney Hill, Craigavad Modification Impact Bungalow; sea view
  1. R-64-2000__2_.pdf
  2. R-64-2000__2_.doc
Eircom v Dynan PO78 [2001] R/67/2000 Diamond Gdns, Finaghy Objectors Development scheme
  1. R-67-2000.pdf
  2. R-67-2000.doc
McCann v DSD LC82 [2008] 1/51 R/67/2004 Cornmarket, Belfast Costs
  1. R-67-2004.pdf
  2. R-67-2004.doc
Jeffers v DOE PLCA71 [1977] R/7/1977 Donegall Rd, Belfast Blight Reasonable endeavours
  1. R-7-1977.pdf
  2. R-7-1977.doc
Doyle v DOE WS73 [1990] 2/60 R/7/1989 Castledawson Sewerage Scheme Compensation
  1. R-7-1989.doc
  2. R-7-1989.pdf
Throne v DRD (1) RD93 [2011] R/70/2006 Grangefoyle Rd, Bready, Strabane Costs Accommodation works agreement
  1. R-70-2006.doc
  2. R-70-2006.pdf
Throne v DRD (2) RD93 [2011] R/70/2006 Grangefoyle Rd, Bready, Strabane Costs Assessment
  1. R-70-2006 (2).doc
  2. R-70-2006 (2).pdf
Neeson v DOE RD80 [1994] 2/81 R/8/1991 Church St, Dromore Injurious affection Betterment
  1. R-8-1991.doc
  2. R-8-1991.pdf
Napier & Sons PO78 [1992] 7/58 R/8/1992 Upton Cottages, Belfast Extinguishment Unreasonable
  1. R-8-1992.pdf
  2. R-8-1992.doc
Nobel v NIHE LC82 [2004] 8/52 R/8/2004 Glasgow St, Belfast Disturbance Equivalence Garden shed
  1. R-8-2004.doc
  2. R-8-2004.pdf
McKillop v Woods PO78 [2010] R/8/2008 Ormeau Rd, Belfast Costs Standing
  1. R-8-2008.pdf
  2. R-8-2008.doc
Truesdale v NIHE LAC73 [2010] R/81/2006 Ainsworth Dr, Belfast Compensation From temporary to permanent Compulsory Purchase code
  1. R-81-2006.doc
  2. R-81-2006.pdf
Churches' Youth Welfare Council v DOE PLCA71 [1977] R/9/1977 Blythe St, Belfast Blight Reasonable endeavours
  1. R-9-1977.pdf
  2. R-9-1977.doc
White v DOE RD80 [1991] 7/125 R/9/1989 Dundooan, Coleraine Flooding Statutory powers Exercise
  1. R-9-1989.doc
  2. R-9-1989.pdf
Pedlow PO78 [1991] 1/77 R/9/1992 Dunkirk Rd, Waringstown Modification Obsolete Trust
  1. R-9-1992.pdf
  2. R-9-1992.doc
Cunningham v Fegan & Anr​ PO78​ [2011]​ R/22/2010​ Henen's Terrace​, Newry​ Costs ​Non-contentious aspects
  1. R-22-2010 (Word)
  2. R-22-2010 (PDF)
Johnston v Dawson & Anr ​PO78 [2011]​ ​R/43/2010 ​Upper Rd, Greenisland ​Benefit Sufficient weight - Intrusion​
  1. R-43-2010 (Word)

  2. R-43-2010 (PDF)
Somers & Ors v DRD​ LC82​ [2012]​ R/8-10/2009​ Windyhill Rd, Limavady​ Injurious affection​
  1. R/8-10/2009 (Word)
  2. R/8-10/2009 (PDF)
Goodwin & Ors v DRD​ LC82​ [2012]​ R/36-37, 46 & 50/2009 & R/9/2010​ Drumnafern, Ballygawley, Dungannon and Dromore​ Admissibility​ Expert evidence​
  1. R/36-37, 46 & 50/2009 & R/9/2010​ (Word)
  2. R/36-37, 46 & 50/2009 & R/9/2010​ (PDF)
Johnston v NIHE​ LC82​ [2012]​ R/48/2010​ Stanhope Dr, Belfast​ Jurisdiction​ Stay​
  1. R/48/2010 (Word)
  2. R/48/2010 (PDF)​
​Gillespie v NIHE LC82​ [2012]​ R/35/2011​ Kitchener St, Belfast​ ​Costs ​Disturbance
  1. R/35/2011 (Word)
  2. R/35/2011 (PDF)
Reilly v DRD (1) PBO81 [2012] R/10/2011 Frosses Rd, Cloughmills Blight Reasonable endeavours Material detriment
  1. R/10/2011 (Word)
  2. R/10/2011 (PDF)
Johnson v Dawson & Anr (2) PO78 [2012] R/43/2010 Upper Rd, Greenisland Costs Amount
  1. R/43/2010 (Word)
  2. R/43/2010 (PDF)
Johnston v NIHE (2) LC82 [2012] R/48/2010 Stanhope Dr, Belfast Costs Jurisdiction Stay
  1. R/48/2010 (Word)
  2. R/48/2010 (PDF)
Cunningham v Fegan & Anr (2) PO 78 [2012] R/22/2010 Helen’s Terrace, Newry Costs Amount – County Court rules
  1. R/22/2010 (Word)
  2. R/22/2010 (PDF)
Kerr v NIHE LC82 [2013] R/37/2010 Moltke St, Belfast Compensation Disturbance Negative equity and Human Rights
  1. R/37/2010 (Word)
  2. R/37/2010 (PDF)
Reilly v DRD (2) PB081 [2013] R/10/2011 Frosses Rd, Cloughmills Costs Proportionate award Losing party “won” on a major issue
  1. R/10/2011 (Word)
  2. R/10/2011 (PDF)
O’Neill v DRD PB081 [2013] R/21-23/2011 Foreglen Rd, Claudy Blight Reasonable endeavours Multiple properties
  1. R/21-23/2011 (Word)
  2. R/21-23/2011 (PDF)
Hunt & Anr v Belvoir Golf Club PO78 [2013] R/86/2007 Church Rd, Newtownbreda Restrictive covenant Opposition Loss of amenity
  1. R/86/2007 (Word)
  2. R/86/2007 (PDF)
Hindes v NIHE LC82 [2013] R/38/2012 Monarch St, Belfast Compensation Disturbance Horn v Sunderland
  1. R/38/2012 (Word)
  2. R/38/2012 (PDF)
McLaughlin v Derry CC LC82​ ​[2013] ​R/35/2010 Donnybrewer Rd, Londonderry​ Compensation​ ​Life interest ​Marriage Value
  1. R/35/2010 (Word)
  2. R/35/2010 (PDF)
Johnston v NIHE (3) LC82 [2013] R/48/2010 Stanhope Dr, Belfast Costs Amount Witness of Fact
  1. R/48/2010 (Word)
  2. R/48/2010 (PDF)
Lawlor PO78 [2013] R/14/2013 Montalto Ct, Ballynahinch Covenant Modification Beneficiary
  1. R/14/2013 (Word)
  2. R/14/2013 (PDF)
Thompson v Twemlow PO78 [2013] R/12/2010 Old Cultra Rd, Holywood Costs Amount  
  1. R/12/2010 (Word)
  2. R/12/2010 (PDF)
McMurray v NIHE (3) LC82 [2013] R/37/2011 Kitchener St, Belfast Compensation Comparable Evidence Market value at date of sale
  1. R/37/2011 (Word)
  2. R/37/2011 (PDF)
Robinson v DRD LGA72 [2013] R/10/2013 Shore Rd, Greenisland Costs Allocation Withdrawal
  1. R/10/2013 (Word)
  2. R/10/2013 (PDF)
Murphy v NIHE PBO81 [2013] R/32/2012 Stratheden St, Belfast Costs Case settled prior to hearing  
  1. R/32/2012 (Word)
  2. R/32/2012 (PDF)
Killen v DRD LC82 [2013] R/38/2011 Cloghole Rd, Campsie Compensation Severance and injurious affection  
  1. R/38/2011 (Word)
  2. R/38/2011 (PDF)
Bradley & Anr v NIHE LC82 [2014] R/34 & 35/2012 Clanchattan St & Queen Victoria Gdns,  Belfast Compensation Damage due to vandalism  
  1. R/34 & 35/2012 (Word)
  2. R/34 & 35/2012 (PDF)
Brickkiln Waste v NIE (1) EO92 [2014] R/41/2009 Electra Rd, Maydown Compensation for grant of necessary wayleave Basis of compensation  
  1. R/41/2009 (Word)
  2. R/41/2009 (PDF)

Key to Legislation

AER71. Aerodromes Act (NI) 1971

AL19. Acquisition of Land (Assessment of Compensation) Act 1919

BGLA85. Betting, Gaming, Lotteries & Amusements (NI) Order 1985

BTA64. Business Tenancies Act (NI) 1964

BTO96. Business Tenancies (NI) Order 1996

BO73. Drainage (NI) Order 1973

EO92. Electricity (NI) Order 1992

HO81. Housing (NI) Order 1981

LAC73. Land Acquisition & Compensation (NI) Order 1973

LC82. Land Compensation (NI) Order 1982

LDV65. Land Development Values (Compensation) Act (NI) 1965

LE71. Leasehold (Enlargement & Extension) Act (NI) 1971

LG72. Local Government Act (NI) 1972

LO90. Licensing (NI) Order 1990

MD69. Mineral Development Act (NI) 1969

PLCA71. Planning & Land Compensation Act (NI) 1971

PBO81. Planning Blight (Compensation) (NI) Order 1981

PO72. Planning (NI) Order 1972

PO78. Property (NI) Order 1978

PO91. Planning (NI) Order 1991

RD48. Roads Act (NI) 1948

RD80. Roads (NI) Order 1980

RD93. Roads (NI) Order 1993

RO72. Rates (NI) Order 1972

RO77. Rates (NI) Order 1977

RT81. Road Traffic (NI) Order 1981

WS73. Water & Sewerage Services (NI) Order 1973​